You signed the paperwork, and somewhere in the fine print your agent disclosed they were representing both you and the seller. This is called dual agency, and while it’s legal in California, it comes with real risks buyers often don’t fully understand until something goes wrong.
What dual agency actually means
Dual agency happens when the same real estate brokerage — sometimes even the same individual agent — represents both the buyer and the seller in the same transaction. California allows this, but only with the knowledge and consent of both parties, and the agent must give each side a written agency disclosure and confirm the dual agency in writing. The agent is still supposed to act as a fiduciary to both sides, which is a difficult, sometimes impossible, balancing act.
Why it’s risky for buyers
A dual agent legally can’t fully advocate for you the way a buyer’s-only agent can. They cannot, for example, tell you that the seller will accept less than the listing price, or share the seller’s motivations or bargaining position, without the seller’s permission (Civil Code § 2079.21). A dual agent must still disclose known material facts about the property to you; the conflict shows up in how hard the agent pushes on your behalf. In practice, this means:
- You may get less candid advice about negotiating price or requesting repairs
- The agent has a financial incentive to see the deal close — they earn a commission either way, and a full commission (or close to it) if they represent both sides
- Red flags the agent may have observed can get downplayed rather than raised, to avoid jeopardizing the deal
Your consent must be informed
Dual agency isn’t automatically improper — but your consent to it must be real, informed consent, not a signature buried among a stack of disclosure forms you didn’t have explained to you. If you didn’t understand what dual agency meant, what it limited the agent from doing for you, or you felt pressured to sign, that consent may not hold up.
Signs dual agency created a problem in your transaction
- The agent discouraged you from getting an independent inspection, or rushed you through inspection contingencies
- The agent didn’t flag something they clearly should have known about the property
- You later learned facts about the property’s condition that the agent likely knew but never told you
- You felt pushed toward closing rather than advised objectively
What you can do
If you believe dual agency compromised the advice or disclosures you received, you may have a breach of fiduciary duty claim, separate from any claim against the seller directly. Depending on the facts, remedies can include damages tied to the agent’s breach and, where the agent was disloyal, acted in bad faith or took a secret profit, giving back the commission.
That claim is not limited to the brokerage. In Horiike v. Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage Co. (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1024, the California Supreme Court held that when one brokerage represents both sides, the salesperson who worked with the seller owes the buyer the same fiduciary duty the brokerage does.
Under the C.A.R. purchase agreement, most of these disputes go to mediation before anyone can file suit. If yours is headed there, see what a lawyer does for a buyer at a C.A.R. mediation.
How to protect yourself going forward
If you’re currently shopping for a home and are offered dual agency (or are already in a dual agency arrangement), ask direct questions: what exactly can and can’t the agent tell you, and are you comfortable with those limits? You’re also entitled to request separate representation.
How Jimmy can help
As both a real estate attorney and a licensed broker in California and Nevada, Jimmy Nguyen understands dual agency from the inside — how it’s supposed to work, and how it sometimes doesn’t. If something about your transaction felt off, it’s worth a conversation.
Undisclosed dual agency is one of the agent-misconduct claims Jimmy handles in his California real estate law practice.
The fastest way to get a useful answer is to write out what happened — a few sentences is plenty. Email jimmy@lawjn.com or use the form below for a free case evaluation.
