Short answer
When a builder sells homes in a subdivision under a Department of Real Estate public report, a state regulation sets the floor for the deposit: the builder’s contract must provide that if escrow does not close on time, the builder orders the money refunded unless it has a valid liquidated damages claim, and it can collect that claim only through the procedures the regulation allows. That claim has to meet the same Civil Code rules as a resale, including separate initials and the 3% presumption for a home you intend to live in. If the builder sends you a 20-day notice and demand for the deposit, a written objection to escrow within that window is what keeps the money in escrow.
You signed with a builder, put down a deposit, maybe paid for upgrades, and now something has gone wrong. The completion date slipped, your loan fell through, you learned something nobody told you, or the builder says you are in default and the deposit is theirs.
A new-construction purchase is not a resale with a newer house. The contract is different, the deposit is held under different rules, and a few protections exist that a resale buyer never sees. This post is for buyers of a new single-family home, townhome or condominium from a California builder.
How a new-construction deposit is different
The builder usually writes the contract. Many builders use their own purchase agreement, drafted for the builder. Some sales use the California Association of REALTORS® new-construction forms instead (the New Construction Purchase Agreement, the Already-Built Subdivision Purchase Agreement and the Condominium Conversion Subdivision Purchase Agreement). Either way, the only contract that matters is the one you signed. Builder contracts commonly address the completion date and how far it can move, what counts as a buyer default, what happens to upgrade and option payments, and how disputes get resolved. Read your own for each of those before you take a position.
The state regulates the project before the first home is sold. In California, a project of five or more lots, or a condominium project of five or more units, is generally a “subdivision” under the Subdivided Lands Act (Business and Professions Code §§ 11000 and 11004.5). The builder cannot sell homes in it without first getting a public report from the Real Estate Commissioner (§ 11018.2), and it must give you a copy of the report before you sign a binding contract and take your signed receipt (§ 11018.1). Some offerings are exempt, and a small infill project may fall below the thresholds, so ask whether your project has a public report and keep your copy.
Your money is supposed to be protected while the home is built. The Act requires the money a buyer pays toward the purchase to go into an escrow or trust account until title is delivered, or to be protected another way the Commissioner approves, such as a bond (§§ 11013.2 and 11013.4). Under some of those alternatives the builder may have use of the funds before closing. Ask the builder, in writing, where your deposit is held and under which arrangement.
You do not get a Transfer Disclosure Statement. The Civil Code’s seller disclosure statement does not apply to sales that must be preceded by a public report (Civil Code § 1102.2(a)). That does not free the builder from the general rule that a seller must disclose known facts that materially affect the property’s value or desirability and that the buyer could not reasonably discover. Courts apply that common-law duty even where the statutory form does not apply.
When escrow does not close: the DRE deposit rule
For a builder selling under a public report, a Department of Real Estate regulation sets the floor for what happens to your money (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 10, § 2791).
- Refund if escrow fails to close. The builder’s contract must provide that if escrow does not close by the contract date, or a later date both sides agreed to, the builder will order all of the buyer’s purchase money refunded within 15 days. The exception is a liquidated damages claim that meets the rest of the regulation.
- Third-party charges must be listed. The contract may allow charges against your deposit for things like credit reports, escrow, title reports, appraisals and loan processing, but only if it lists each charge and gives the builder’s estimate of the total.
- Liquidated damages must follow the Civil Code. Any provision that lets the builder keep money because you failed to complete the purchase must conform to Civil Code §§ 1675 through 1678, covered below.
- The builder cannot simply take the money. Unless both sides sign an agreement cancelling the contract, the builder may take your deposit as liquidated damages only after a court decides it is entitled to it, after an arbitrator decides it (if the contract provides for arbitration), or through the notice procedure in the next item.
- The 20-day notice and demand. The contract may let escrow release your deposit to the builder if the builder serves written notice that you are in default, demanding a stated amount, and you do not give escrow a written objection within 20 days after you receive it. This is the deadline to watch. If you receive a notice like this, put your written objection in escrow’s hands inside the 20 days, and keep proof of delivery.
- If the builder had use of your money, it must put funds equal to everything you paid back into escrow as soon as it alleges you defaulted.
The liquidated damages rules
A liquidated damages clause fixes in advance what the seller keeps if the buyer defaults. The builder still has to show that you were the one in default. A buyer who cancelled for a reason the contract allows owes nothing under the clause. (On a resale, that usually means cancelling inside a contingency; see what a buyer gives up by removing contingencies.)
For a home of one to four units that you intended, when you signed, to live in, Civil Code § 1675 sets the rules:
- The clause is valid only to the extent of money you actually paid.
- If the amount kept is 3% of the purchase price or less, it is valid unless you prove it is unreasonable.
- If the amount kept is more than 3%, the clause is invalid unless the builder proves the amount is reasonable. A builder who cannot prove it loses the clause, not just the excess.
- Reasonableness is judged by the circumstances when the contract was made and by the price and terms of any resale of the same home within six months after the default.
The 3% figure decides who has to prove what. It is not a cap.
Two more requirements apply. The clause must be separately signed or initialed by each party, and in a printed contract it must appear in at least 10-point bold type or 8-point bold type in contrasting red (§ 1677). If the deposit was increased later, each increase needs its own separately initialed clause, and the total must still satisfy § 1675 (§ 1678). If you paid in stages, check the initials for each one.
The special rule for new condominiums. Section 1675(f) adds a rule for the first sale of a newly built attached condominium unit in a structure of 10 or more condominium units, where the builder keeps more than 3% of the price. The builder must do an accounting of its costs and revenues for the unit after the unit resells, must make reasonable efforts to reduce its losses, and must refund whatever it kept above the greater of 3% of the original price or its actual losses shown by that accounting. The refund goes to your last known address. The timing can stretch out: the refund is due within 90 days after the close of escrow on all the units in the structure, though the accounting comes sooner if a new qualified buyer contracts for your unit. In this one situation the builder does not lose the whole clause for keeping more than 3%. It owes back the excess.
If the clause fails. Without a valid liquidated damages clause, the builder can keep only the damages it proves: generally the contract price minus the home’s value at the time of the breach, plus consequential damages (Civil Code § 3307). A buyer whose payments exceed the seller’s actual damages may recover the excess, even after a willful default (Freedman v. Rector, Wardens & Vestrymen of St. Matthias Parish (1951) 37 Cal.2d 16). A deposit labeled “nonrefundable” is not a liquidated damages clause, and California law disfavors forfeitures (Civil Code § 3275).
If the home was not finished when you signed. Section 1675 speaks of a contract to buy “a dwelling” and does not say how it treats a home that is still to be built. Under a public report the question rarely matters, because the Department of Real Estate regulation requires the builder’s clause to conform to §§ 1675 through 1678. For a small project sold without a public report, the statute’s text does not settle it. The difference shows up above 3%: outside § 1675, a clause is tested under Civil Code §§ 1676 and 1671(b), where it stands unless the buyer proves it was unreasonable when the contract was made. The separate-initials rule in § 1677 applies either way.
The written demand under § 1057.3. If your deposit is sitting in escrow and the purchase did not close by the contract date, Civil Code § 1057.3 may give you a second tool. On property of one to four residential units that the buyer is to occupy, a party who does not sign the escrow release within 30 days after a written demand, and who is not holding the money to resolve a good-faith dispute, can be liable for the funds, treble damages of at least $100 and no more than $1,000, and attorney’s fees in an action to enforce it. A builder that claims you defaulted may say there is a good-faith dispute, and the statute gives no remedy against a party who withholds the money to resolve one. Treat the demand as leverage, not as a sure result. How to Get Your Earnest Money Deposit Back in California walks through the demand.
Cancelling because of a change or something not disclosed
Material changes. Once a project has been submitted to the Department of Real Estate, the builder may not materially change the setup of the offering without first notifying the department in writing (Business and Professions Code § 11012). The department’s regulation lists examples of material changes, including a change in how buyers’ purchase money is handled, newly discovered hazards such as adverse geologic conditions, a change in the configuration of the lot or unit from the map the report was based on, and the builder’s inability to keep commitments it made in its application (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 10, § 2800). The statute itself creates a notice duty, not a cancellation right. Whether you can cancel and get your money back because of a change depends on your contract. The C.A.R. new-construction forms, for example, build public report contingency and refund rights around a material change. A builder’s own contract may or may not.
If you bought under a conditional public report. A builder may sign contracts before the final public report issues, under a conditional public report, but title cannot pass until the final report is issued. In that case the arrangement must provide for return of the entire amount you paid if the final report is not issued during the conditional report’s term, or if you are dissatisfied with the final report because of a material change (Business and Professions Code § 11018.12(e)(3)). Your receipt for the report should show which kind of report you received.
Nondisclosure. California lets a party rescind a contract when its consent was obtained through fraud (Civil Code § 1689(b)(1)). Whether a builder’s silence about a particular fact rises to that level depends on what the builder knew, whether the fact was material, and whether you could have found it yourself. Start with the public report and anything the builder gave you before you signed.
Disputes, mediation and arbitration
Read the dispute resolution section of your contract before you send anything. Some builder contracts send disputes to arbitration or another private process. For contracts used under a public report, Department of Real Estate rules require any such process to meet minimum standards, including that the builder advance the fees to start it, that a neutral person preside, and that it be held in the county where the subdivision is located unless the parties agree otherwise (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 10, § 2791.8). An arbitration clause covering the builder’s claim to your deposit must follow procedures equivalent in substance to the American Arbitration Association’s commercial rules and must cover every claim between you and the builder under the contract (§ 2791(c)(3)).
The C.A.R. new-construction forms require mediation, with the seller advancing the mediation fee, and limit arbitration to disputes before closing. Under the C.A.R. resale form’s mediation clause, courts have held that a party who sues without first offering to mediate, or who refuses a request to mediate, loses its right to attorney fees even if it wins (see mediation before you sue). If your contract has a clause like that, request mediation in writing early and accept any request from the builder.
Defect claims after closing are a separate track under California’s Right to Repair Act (Civil Code § 895 and following), which requires notice to the builder before suit.
What to gather and do right now
- Find the contract and every addendum, including deposit increase pages, upgrade and option agreements, and any extension of the completion date. Check who initialed each liquidated damages clause.
- Find your public report and the receipt you signed. Note the date and whether it was a final or conditional report.
- Ask the builder in writing where your deposit and upgrade payments are held: in escrow, in a trust account, or with the builder under a bond.
- Build a timeline with dates: contract signed, each deposit paid, scheduled completion and closing dates, every notice you sent or received.
- If you received a 20-day notice and demand, make sure escrow has your written objection inside the 20 days, and keep proof of delivery. The 20 days keep running while you look for a lawyer.
- Do not sign a cancellation or release that gives up your claim to the deposit until you know what you are giving up.
- Compute the deposit as a percentage of the price. That number, and whether the home has resold since, shapes the whole analysis.
How Jimmy can help
Jimmy Nguyen has been a California real estate attorney since 2012 and is a licensed California real estate broker. He reads builder contracts, public reports and escrow instructions for what decides these disputes: when escrow was supposed to close, what notice the builder sent, and whether the liquidated damages clause was ever valid.
If a builder is holding or threatening to keep a deposit you need back, write to Jimmy with the total you have paid (deposit and upgrades), what the builder says you did wrong, and the date of any notice you received. Those three facts tell him quickly how much is really at stake and how much time you have. Deposit disputes are the core of his earnest money deposit dispute practice.
Email jimmy@lawjn.com with those three facts, or use the form below.
